Here is all products. Apples and cheese grate on a coarse grater. Fish, boiled in salted water with spices finely chop. Add chopped nuts, horseradish, pepper and salt. Nuts I walnuts. Mayonnaise and mix well. To be honest, I changed the number of ingredients: I have fish more, and less cheese. Yes, and I don't use mayonnaise, so I have homemade yogurt. Was very "cool." Said my husband. The freshness from the radish and apples, fish and nuts is felt, but the cheese not :) Perhaps due to the fact that I broke his number.